Metal Vs Wood Box Spring

We may earn commissions from affiliate links on our site(s) at no extra cost to our readers. Commissions do not affect our opinions or evaluations.

What is a box spring?

A box spring is a bed base that is typically made of wood or metal and is filled with springs or a metal grid. It is designed to sit directly under a mattress and provide support and comfort. Box springs are often used with innerspring mattresses, but they can also be used with some foam mattresses.

Why do you need one?

Whether or not you need a box spring depends on the type of mattress you have and your personal preferences. Some mattresses, such as foam mattresses, do not require a box spring. However, other mattresses, such as innerspring mattresses, do benefit from the support that a box spring provides.

Here are some of the reasons why you might need a box spring:

  • To provide support for your mattress: A box spring can help prevent your mattress from sagging and losing its shape. This is especially important for innerspring mattresses, which are made up of coils that can compress over time and lose their ability to provide support. A box spring can help distribute the weight evenly across the mattress, preventing it from sagging.
  • To improve airflow: A box spring can help keep your mattress cooler by allowing air to circulate underneath it. This is important for all mattresses, but it is especially important for memory foam mattresses, which can trap heat. The springs in a box spring help create space for air to flow, which can help keep your mattress cool and comfortable.
  • To raise the height of your bed: A box spring can make it easier to get in and out of bed, especially for people with mobility issues. The extra height can also make it easier to change the sheets or make the bed.
  • To add comfort: A box spring can make your mattress more comfortable by providing a cushioning surface that reduces pressure points, leading to a more restful night's sleep.
  • To protect your mattress: The springs and cover of a box spring can help keep dirt and moisture away from your mattress, which can help prolong its lifespan.

What to Consider When Choosing a Box Spring

  • The size of your mattress: Make sure to choose a box spring that is the same size as your mattress.
  • Your mattress type: If you have an innerspring mattress, you will need a box spring that is designed for innerspring mattresses. Foam mattresses do not require a box spring, but they can benefit from the support of a platform bed frame.
  • Your personal preferences: Some people prefer the traditional look of an innerspring box spring, while others prefer the sleek look of a platform bed frame. Consider your own style and preferences when making a decision.
  • Your budget: Box springs can range in price from a few hundred dollars to a few thousand dollars. Decide how much you are willing to spend on a box spring before you start shopping.

Pros and Cons of the Metal Box Spring

Pros

  • Durable: Metal box springs are made of strong materials, such as steel or aluminum, which makes them very durable. They can withstand a lot of wear and tear, and they are less likely to sag than wood box springs.
  • Long-lasting: Metal box springs can last for many years, making them a good investment.
  • Easy to care for: Metal box springs are easy to clean and maintain. You can simply wipe them down with a damp cloth.
  • Versatile: Metal box springs can be used with a variety of mattresses, including innerspring mattresses, memory foam mattresses, and latex mattresses. This makes them a good option for people who are looking for a versatile foundation that can be used with different types of mattresses.
  • Affordable: Metal box springs are typically more affordable than wood box springs. This makes them a good option for people who are on a budget.

A person stretching on a bed with a metal box spring, in a bright room.

Cons

  • Noisy: Metal box springs can be noisy when people move around on them. This can be a problem for people who are light sleepers. However, there are also metal box springs that are designed to be quiet, so it is important to do your research before you buy one.
  • Not as stylish: Metal box springs are typically made of metal frames with a wire coil support system. This gives them a more industrial and utilitarian look than wood box springs.
  • Can be difficult to move: Metal box springs can be heavy and difficult to move around on your own. You may need someone to help you set it up.

Pros and Cons of the Wood Box Spring

Pros

  • Comfortable: Wood box springs can be more comfortable than metal box springs because they offer more cushioning. The wood slats on a wood box spring can provide a more gentle and conforming surface for the mattress to rest on, which can help reduce pressure points and improve comfort.
  • Aesthetically pleasing: Wood box springs can add a touch of elegance to your bedroom. They come in a variety of finishes, so you can choose one that matches your decor. Wood box springs can also be made to match the style of your bed frame, creating a cohesive look in your bedroom.
  • Lightweight: Wood springs are typically lighter than metal springs, making them easier to move and transport. This can be a major advantage if you are moving or have difficulty lifting heavy objects.
  • Absorbs movement: Wood is a good insulator, which means that it can help to absorb movement and reduce noise. This can be helpful if you share a bed with a partner or have children who sleep in the same room.

Mattress on wood box spring

Cons

  • More expensive: Wood box springs are typically more expensive than metal box springs. This is because they are made from more expensive materials and require more labor to construct.
  • Can be difficult to find: Wood box springs are not as common as metal box springs, so you may have to do some shopping to find one.
  • Not compatible with all mattresses: Wood box springs are not compatible with all mattresses. Some mattresses, such as memory foam mattresses, require a specific type of foundation.

Metal Box Springs: The Affordable, Durable Option

Metal box springs are a type of bed foundation made of metal frames with wire coil support systems.

The metal frames are typically made of steel or aluminum, and the wire coils are made of steel or tempered steel. The coils are arranged in a grid and held in place by metal bands or clips.

Metal box springs are available in a variety of sizes and finishes to match different bed frames. They are also considered more affordable and durable than wood springs because they are made of less expensive materials, are manufactured in large quantities, and are more resistant to damage.

However, it is important to note that not all metal box springs are created equal. The quality of the metal used, the manufacturing process, and the finishing process all play a role in the durability of the spring. It is also important to choose a metal spring that has the right size and weight capacity for your mattress.

Wood Box Springs: The Classic, Elegant Choice

Wood box springs are a type of bed foundation made of wood planks. They are popular because they are durable, comfortable, and can be customized to fit any mattress.

A hand pressing down on a corner of a box spring, testing its firmness.

The wood planks are typically made of hardwoods, such as maple or oak. The planks are then assembled to form the frame, and wire coils are inserted into the frame and held in place by metal bands or clips.

Wood box springs are considered more elegant than metal box springs because they are made of natural materials, have a traditional design, and can be finished in a variety of colors and finishes. Wood is a natural material that is often associated with luxury and sophistication, and it can give a room a warm and inviting feel. Wood box springs are also often designed in a traditional style that is reminiscent of classic bedroom furniture. This style is often characterized by simple lines and elegant curves.

Finally, wood box springs can be finished in a variety of colors and finishes, which can give them a more elegant look. For example, a wood box spring with a dark stain or a light finish can give a room a more sophisticated look.

Metal vs. Wood Box Springs: A Comparison of Costs, Durability, Assembly, and Noise

Cost

Metal box springs are typically less expensive than wood box springs. This is because metal is a less expensive material than wood, and metal box springs are typically manufactured in larger quantities. If you are on a budget, then a metal box spring is a good option.

Durability

Metal box springs are typically more durable than wood box springs. This is because metal is a stronger material than wood and is less likely to warp or break. However, not all metal box springs are created equal. Look for features like reinforced corners, a sturdy frame, and high-quality materials to ensure maximum durability. Consider the manufacturer's warranty for added peace of mind.

Wood box springs are typically less durable than metal box springs. This is because wood is a softer material than metal and is more susceptible to damage from moisture and pests. However, some wood box springs are made with high-quality materials and can be quite durable.

Assembly

Metal box springs are typically easier to assemble than wood box springs. This is because metal box springs are typically made with fewer parts and are not as heavy as wood box springs. However, some metal box springs may require more assembly than others.

Wood box springs require more time and effort to assemble as they come in pieces that need to be put together using more tools. However, some wood box springs may come pre-assembled or with easy-to-follow instructions.

Noise

Metal box springs are typically louder than wood box springs. This is because the metal coils in metal box springs can squeak when people move around on them. However, some metal box springs have noise-reducing features, such as padding or fabric covering.

Wood box springs are typically quieter than metal box springs. This is because the wood planks in wood box springs are less likely to squeak. However, some wood box springs may still produce noise, especially if they are not made with high-quality materials.

How to Choose the Right Box Spring for Your Mattress

For proper support and give, innerspring and hybrid mattresses need a box spring underneath. Latex and memory foam beds, on the other hand, tend to be heavier and need to be laid on solid, flat, firm surfaces to prevent premature sagging and body impressions.

Box springs are perfect for combination sleepers looking for responsiveness and innerspring beds. Foundations are ideal for stomach and back sleepers on a memory foam mattress. However, it's important to note that box springs will not work for all mattress types. They typically work best with lightweight innerspring mattresses rather than memory foam or latex mattresses.

When in doubt, be sure to check the manufacturer's specifications for your mattress to confirm whether or not it should be used with a box spring. While box springs don't work with all mattress types, some mattress manufacturers actually require a box spring to be used in order for the mattress to be eligible for warranty.

Troubleshooting Common Box Spring Problems

  • Sagging: If your box spring is sagging, it may be time to replace it. However, there are a few things you can do to try to fix the sagging in the meantime. You can try flipping the box spring over, or you can add a plywood board or slats underneath the mattress.
  • Noise: If your box spring is noisy, it may be due to the metal coils rubbing against each other. You can try lubricating the coils with a silicone spray, or you can add a mattress topper to reduce the noise.
  • Squeaking: If your box spring is squeaking, it may be due to the frame rubbing against the mattress. You can try lubricating the frame with a silicone spray, or you can tighten the screws that hold the frame together.
  • Water damage: If your box spring has been exposed to water, it may be damaged and need to be replaced. You can try drying the box spring out, but it may not be possible to completely restore it.
  • Mildew: If your box spring has mildew, it may be due to moisture exposure. You can try cleaning the mildew with a solution of bleach and water, but it may be necessary to replace the box spring.

Wood box spring

Conclusion

Metal and wood box springs are both popular options for supporting mattresses. They each have their own advantages and disadvantages, so the best choice for you will depend on your individual needs and preferences.

If you are looking for an affordable option that is durable and easy to assemble, then a metal box spring may be a good choice for you. If you are looking for a more elegant and quiet option, then a wood box spring may be a better choice.

Here is a table summarizing the key differences between metal and wood box springs:

FeatureMetal Box SpringWood Box Spring
CostTypically less expensiveTypically more expensive
DurabilityMore durableLess durable
AssemblyEasier to assembleMore difficult to assemble
Noise levelNoisierQuieter
Weight capacityHigher weight capacityLower weight capacity
AestheticsMore modern lookMore Elegant look
Dom Abraham

Dom Abraham

As the lead content writer at Sleepiverse. Dom pours his heart into writing mattress reviews, bedding product reviews, and medically-reviewed health articles. Dom is from Portugal and likes to spend his free time writing on the beach as it gives him a sense of comfort. Aside from writing mattress reviews in front of the soothing beach view, Dom likes to experiment with new amazing food ideas.