Best Pillow-Top Mattresses of 2024: Our Expert-Tested Top Picks

The Helix Midnight Luxe Mattress, a standout in the world of pillow-top mattresses, offers a unique blend of comfort and support tailored to a wide range of sleep preferences. It features medium-feel memory foam layers topped with a plush pillow top, making it an ideal choice for those who favor a balance between firm support and a soft, cushioning surface. The mattress is specifically designed to cater to side sleepers and those who frequently toss and turn, providing exceptional pressure point relief. Additionally, the Helix Midnight Luxe offers a choice between two cooling cover options: the breathable and moisture-wicking TENCEL™ cover and the GlacioTex™ Cooling Cover, each designed to regulate temperature and enhance sleep comfort. With its assembly in Arizona and CertiPUR-US® and GREENGUARD Gold certifications, this mattress assures quality, safety, and environmental stewardship.

Further elevating its appeal, the Helix Midnight Luxe features several luxe upgrade options, including zoned lumbar support coils that offer a firmer support under the hips and a softer feel under the shoulders, aligning and cradling the body for optimal comfort. The premium quilted pillow top adds an extra layer of luxury, delivering a hotel-like top layer feel with ultra-cool technology. Recognized and recommended by leading experts in sleep medicine, psychology, and neurobiology, and endorsed by a major chiropractic organization in the United States, the Helix Midnight Luxe stands out as a professionally recommended choice for improving sleep quality. Its hypoallergenic cooling cover options further tailor the sleeping experience to individual needs, making it a versatile choice for a wide range of sleepers.

The Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid Mattress is a superior blend of quality and affordability, designed to provide exceptional sleep without breaking the bank. Featuring a combination of high-quality foams, the mattress offers perfect pressure relief and contouring comfort. The top layers consist of Supreme Response Comfort Foam and VariFlex™ transition foam, ensuring buoyancy, breathability, and top-notch comfort. Additionally, the mattress is equipped with individually encased coils, strategically zoned to support the body where it's needed most. These coils work independently to offer targeted support and relief, including superior motion isolation, making it an excellent choice for partners sharing a bed.

Customizability is a key highlight of the Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid Mattress. It caters to a range of preferences with three firmness options: soft, medium, and firm. For those seeking extra luxury, there's an optional Cozy-as-a-Cloud Cooling Pillow Top, which includes a GlacioTex™ Cooling Cover and a dual layer of pillow top foam for ultimate contouring and pressure point relief. This mattress combines high-density foam layers and premium steel coils, all manufactured in-house for optimal cost and quality control. Emphasizing value, the mattress is designed by master craftsmen and shipped directly to the consumer, eliminating middleman costs and ensuring a premium quality product at an ideal price point.

The PlushBeds Organic Bliss Pillowtop Mattress epitomizes luxury in the realm of pillow-top mattresses, crafted meticulously with the finest quality organic materials. At the heart of this mattress is a 3-inch plush pillowtop layer of GOLS certified organic latex, providing a luxurious and supportive sleeping surface. This layer is further enhanced by additional comfort layers of the same high-grade organic latex. The mattress is enveloped in a soft, sumptuous cover made from GOTS certified organic cotton and wool, offering breathable comfort and effective temperature regulation. It's not just about comfort; this mattress also allows for customizable firmness levels, ensuring a personalized luxury sleeping experience tailored to individual preferences.

In addition to its luxurious feel, the PlushBeds Organic Bliss Mattress is designed with health and environmental responsibility in mind. The organic cotton cover is not only soft and breathable but also free from harmful pesticides or herbicides, ensuring a safe sleeping environment. The mattress features up to 10 lbs. of GOTS-certified organic British wool for natural temperature regulation and moisture absorption. Further, the core of the mattress is made from GOLS-certified organic Arpico latex, offering perfect pressure relief and robust support for the lower back. The mattress's commitment to sustainability is evident in its biodegradable design and socially responsible manufacturing, making it an eco-friendly choice for the discerning sleeper.

The Nolah Evolution 15 Hybrid Mattress is a quintessence of luxury and innovative design, setting a new standard for comfort in pillow-top mattresses. It boasts a plush 15-inch profile, including a sumptuous Euro topper that provides a soft, embracing feel. The mattress is infused with cutting-edge materials like graphite-infused AirFoamICE™, which not only offers luxurious cushioning but also ensures best-in-class cooling. The unique HDMax™ Tri-Zone™ coils are engineered for targeted back support and responsive pressure relief, adapting seamlessly to various sleep positions. Additionally, the mattress is enveloped in a breathable cover made from organic cotton and ArcticTex™, further enhancing the cooling effect and comfort level.

This hybrid mattress is designed and assembled in the U.S.A, reflecting a commitment to quality and craftsmanship. It features multiple layers that work in harmony to deliver unparalleled comfort and support. The seven-layer construction includes high-resilience foam and 8-inch coils, with 13.75 gauge perimeter coils boosting edge support and overall durability. The thoughtful design extends to its environmental credentials, with GREENGUARD Gold certification and CertiPUR-US® certified foam, ensuring safety and sustainability. The mattress is available in various firmness options – Plush, Luxury Firm, or Firm – catering to different comfort preferences. With its blend of advanced materials and thoughtful design, the Nolah Evolution 15 is a standout choice for those seeking the ultimate in mattress comfort.

The Puffy Monarch Hybrid Mattress is a luxury model that excels in providing a blend of comfort, support, and temperature regulation, making it an ideal choice for couples. It features a comprehensive 12-layer design that includes hypoallergenic alpaca wool and a cool-to-the-touch quilted cover to enhance breathability and create a cloud-like feel. The exclusive use of latex and cushioning foams ensures unparalleled spinal alignment and pressure relief. Additionally, the soft pillow top layer is specifically designed to wick away moisture, further enhancing the sleep experience by keeping both partners cool and comfortable throughout the night.

For couples, the mattress's construction offers a unique combination of features that cater to different sleep preferences and movements. The Monarch Latex Response Layer and Reflexive Memory Foam adapt to each person's shifts and positions, providing responsive support without disturbing the other. The inclusion of 6” Contour-Adapt Coils absorbs motion, ensuring that movements are isolated and both partners enjoy an undisturbed sleep. Made in the USA, this cooling-infused mattress suits all sleeper types and offers a plush yet supportive feel that is especially beneficial for couples seeking a mattress that meets both their needs.

The Birch Luxe Natural Mattress epitomizes the fusion of luxury and natural cooling properties, designed to provide exceptional sleep comfort. This premium mattress boasts a quilted organic cotton Euro top and a soft, breathable matelassé woven cotton cover. It features three layers of organic cashmere and wool, known for their breathability and temperature-regulating qualities, ensuring a cool and comfortable sleep experience. The mattress also includes zoned lumbar support for enhanced contouring and full edge support for structural integrity throughout. The medium-firm feel of the mattress caters to all sleep positions, providing just the right balance of comfort and support. Certified by GOTS and GREENGUARD Gold, the Birch Luxe Natural Mattress meets rigorous standards for organic materials and safety, ensuring a healthy sleep environment.

Key to the Birch Luxe Natural Mattress's design is its focus on natural breathability and cooling properties. It is crafted with premium natural and organic materials like ultra-fine cashmere, naturally hygroscopic wool, and breathable natural latex, all working together to maximize airflow and temperature regulation. These materials not only provide comfort but also wick away moisture, keeping sleepers cool throughout the night. The mattress’s zoned lumbar support and natural latex layers offer comfortable contouring and body cradling, reducing stress on the lower back while providing pressure relief. The Birch Luxe Natural Mattress is also known for its eco-responsible production credentials, adding to its appeal for environmentally conscious consumers.

The Bear Star Hybrid Mattress represents a fusion of modern sleep technology and traditional comfort, making it a standout in the pillow-top mattress category. At 13 inches thick, this premium mattress combines Serene Gel Foam with individually-encased coils, striking an ideal balance between comfort and support. The mattress's top features include a moisture-wicking, cool-to-the-touch hand-quilted cover with HydroCool® technology and Celliant® fiber, enhancing the sleep surface's coolness and drying speed. This cover works in conjunction with the Serene Gel Foam layer to offer cooling and pressure relief, making it an excellent choice for sleepers who tend to sleep hot or experience discomfort during the night.

Beyond its cooling capabilities, the Bear Star Hybrid Mattress excels in providing responsive support tailored to various body types and sleep positions. The Responsive Comfort Foam adapts effectively, offering additional airflow and pressure relief. For robust support across the entire mattress, it incorporates high-density support foam and extra-strong edge coils. These features not only enhance the mattress's durability but also reduce roll-off, ensuring a stable and comfortable sleep experience. Additionally, its GREENGUARD Gold Certification by UL signifies a commitment to low emissions and fewer harsh chemicals, ensuring a cleaner and healthier sleep environment.

The PlushBeds Signature Bliss Pillowtop Mattress is a pinnacle of luxury and support, handcrafted in California using the world's finest materials. This exceptional mattress features a 3-inch plush pillowtop layer of organic latex, offering a soothing, pressure-relieving surface. Beneath this, a 5-zoned, fabric-encased coil core provides superior motion suppression and robust edge support, making it ideal for those who share a bed or require a stable, supportive sleep surface. The combination of certified organic latex, organic wool, and organic cotton in the mattress construction not only ensures a luxurious feel but also promotes a cool, comfortable, and dry sleep environment, critical for maintaining optimal body temperature throughout the night.

Emphasizing health and environmental consciousness, the Signature Bliss Mattress is crafted with GOLS-certified organic Dunlop latex, GOTS-certified organic British wool, and GOTS-Certified organic cotton. These materials are not only superior in quality but also adhere to the most stringent organic standards, ensuring a non-toxic, hypoallergenic sleep environment. Additionally, the mattress is GreenGuard Gold and eco-INSTITUT certified, guaranteeing it is free of harmful chemicals and allergens. The handcrafted quality, coupled with a lifetime warranty and a 100-night money-back guarantee, underscores the brand's confidence in its product, reinforcing its reputation for quality, reliability, and service. Notably, the Signature Bliss has garnered thousands of verified reviews and recommendations from chiropractors and orthopedic specialists, particularly for its superior support.