Serta Perfect Sleeper Castara Pillow Top Mattress Review

We may earn commissions from affiliate links on our site(s) at no extra cost to our readers. Commissions do not affect our opinions or evaluations.
notepad icon

Expert's Note

The Serta Perfect Sleeper Castara is an innerspring mattress with a pillowtop design that is both comfortable and supportive. It also features a 10-year limited guarantee.

However, if going a bit higher with the budget is an option for you, then consider going with better new alternatives to the Serta Perfect Sleeper Castara.

In our testing below, we found that the Serta Perfect Sleeper Castara's low price tag is due to critical compromises in the quality. You simply can't get a good quality hybrid mattress at such a low price point.

Continue reading below to see our verdict about the Serta Perfect Sleeper Castara, and the better options you should consider.

Too tired to read the detailed review & just want to know what mattress you should buy? Jump to the conclusion here.

Overview

Serta Perfect Sleeper Castara Pillow Top

Serta Perfect Sleeper Castara Pillow Top

The Serta Perfect Sleeper Castara Pillow Top is a budget-friendly hybrid mattress. The Castara's highlight feature is the pillow top that promises a wider sleeping surface for couples.

Final Sleepiverse Rating

3

out of 5

3 stars icon
Product Details
Mattress Material icon
MATERIAL
Hybrid
trial period icon
TRIAL
PERIOD
N/A
shipping icon
FREE SHIPPING & RETURNS
N/A
warranty icon
WARRANTY
Depends on Retailer
price icon
PRICE
RANGE
$449 - $749
This mattress is a good choice for:
Side Sleeping
Side Sleeping

Ideal for lightweight, average weight, and heavyweight side sleepers.

green verified icon
Verified Brand
Expert Pick

Layla Hybrid Mattress

GET $200 OFF + 2 FREE Premium Pillows + Extra $50 Off at Checkout

clock icon
Expires Soon
people icon
Many People Bought Recently
coupons icon
Few Coupons Remaining
Exclusive Discount - Limited Time
Check Price

serta perfect sleeper castara

The Serta Perfect Sleeper Castara is an innerspring mattress with a pillowtop design that is both comfortable and supportive. It also features a 10-year limited guarantee.

I would say they are tolerable if you want a springy or bouncy sensation.

Don't waste your time or money on this boring bed. There are far preferable alternatives.

We believe that cheaping out on a mattress is never a good decision. A mattress is an investment to your health, and through our testing we found that the Serta Perfect Sleeper Castara's low price tag comes at the price of your spinal alignment.

We recommend that you get one of the alternatives we discuss below. Most notably, the Layla Hybrid Mattress, hey produce an innerspring/foam hybrid mattress that is both luxurious and durable. The best customer service in the business, available around the clock.

Pros

  • Good for side sleepers
  • Extremely low price point - However, this comes at the price of quality.

Cons

  • Detailed specs about the product are lacking - This is a big red flag when it comes to the materials used, allergens, possible fiberglass use, low quality memory foam, etc.
  • High motion transfer - Despite what the marketing for this mattress states, its motion isolation is really not that good. If you're a couple, we advise steering away from this mattress. There are much better hybrid mattresses that offer better motion isolation.
  • Low quality materials - The materials used in the Serta Perfect Sleeper are far from perfect. Compare it to a proper mattress like the Layla Hybrid, and you see a huge difference.

Firmness, Feel, and Comfort for the Serta Perfect Sleeper Castara Pillow Top

Serta's Perfect Sleeper Castara Pillow Top is available in a Luxuriously Plush Firmness (give-or-take a 3-4 on a 1-10 firmness scale).

This cushioned design is specifically made for people who have trouble sleeping on their sides due to pressure spots (neck, shoulder, arms, low back, hips, etc).

Should be avoided by those who regularly or occasionally sleep on their stomachs or backs. If you prefer to sleep on your back or stomach, you won't have the solid support you need to maintain proper spinal and cervical alignment.

Despite extensive enfoldment, the top design does a decent job of keeping the sleeping surface flat and relatively even.

Side Sleeping

If you prefer to sleep on your side, go no further than the Serta Perfect Sleeper Castara Pillow Top.

Always go for the supplest option they have. Contact them if you're confused about which model it is.

Count on lots of back up during the rough patches (specifically your low back, hips, neck, shoulders). As the body sinks downward, the top layer of foams cushions it.

When sleeping on your side, it's important to keep your shoulders, hips, and torso in a neutral position. Constant stress on a neuron or pain receptor might damage them over time.

Back and Stomach Sleeping

If you like to sleep on your stomach or back, you may not be happy with the Serta Perfect Sleeper Castara Pillow Top.

The firmness level options range from 6.5 out of 10 for luxury firm to 7 out of 10 for firm and 8 out of 10 for extremely firm. Call or message them if you need help identifying the model.

There will be adequate space for your neck and spine (specifically your lumbar). The top foams are fairly firm and help keep your back in a straight position.

For the best results when lying on your back or stomach, it's important to look for a mattress that won't push too much on your hips. That's a certain way to jiggle your spine out of place.

Construction, Design, and Quality for the Serta Perfect Sleeper Castara Pillow Top Mattress

Serta Perfect Sleeper Castara Pillow Top Mattress

Although Serta is not providing detailed description of the specs of the layers used in the Perfect Sleeper Castara Pillow Top Mattress (which is a big red flag).

We found the layers used to be as follows:

  • Bottom Layer - made of pocketed coils (not great quality coils).
  • Transition Layer - padded with medium firmness foam.
  • Top Layer - gel foam for pressure relief (also nowhere near good gel memory foam)
  • Top Design - pillow-top to increase the sleeping surface
  • Cover - made cooling fabric, not bad, but also nothing to write about.

Edge Support for the Serta Perfect Sleeper Castara Pillow Top Mattress

We found the edge support in the Serta Perfect Sleeper to be really good due to the hybrid design. Most hybrid mattresses never fail in this department.

Be aware that even if a mattress first feels supportive, it may quickly lose that feeling if it is made with low-quality materials, which we found to be the case with the Serta Perfect Sleeper.

Sleeping area is reduced due to lack of proper edge support (which is not desirable, especially if you sleep with a partner).

Motion Isolation for the Serta Perfect Sleeper Castara Pillow Top

At first, we thought that this model from Serta would show satisfactory performance when it comes to motion isolation due to the pillow top design.

However, we found that motion isolation suffered greatly here, probably due to the quality of the coils used.

Please take notice that the amount of motion transfer between the two sides of the bed indicates the amount of movement that occurs between the two sides. It's important to invest in a mattress with exceptional motion isolation if you or your partner like to move around a lot during the night.

To sum it all up: less motion transfer means more restful sleep and a more contented existence.

For this reason alone, we recommend that you definitely go with one of the recommended alternatives stated below.

Return Policy for the Serta Perfect Sleeper Castara

This is all you need to know about our return policy:

Return policies vary by store (since you can not purchase it from their site).

This is a huge disadvantage when you compare it to online specialized mattress brands. Customers consistently report feeling betrayed by the subpar after-sale customer support of mattress physical stores compared to online mattress brands (especially the thoroughly tested brands we compiled a list of here).

Exchange Policy for the Serta Perfect Sleeper Castara

Where you make your purchase can affect whether or not you are able to return an item (since you can not purchase it from their site).

Look for a company that will accept returns and not charge you a fortune if you accidentally buy the wrong size.

Warranty for the Serta Perfect Sleeper Castara

We found that most physical stores retail this mattress with a 10-year warranty. This is inline with most mattress warranties out there.

However, from customer reports and our experience, you don't want to go through a warranty claim with physical stores. We recommend going for an online proper luxury brand instead for a better experience.

With the quality of the Serta Perfect Sleeper, we think you will need the warranty sooner than later.

We believe you should fork up for something like the Layla Hybrid or any of the comparable alternatives down below, which will serve you for decades to come, instead of buying something that will need a replacement soon like the Serta Perfect Sleeper.

Serta Perfect Sleeper Castara Pricing

SizePrice
Twin$449
Twin XL$574
Full$574
Queen$599
King$749
Cal King$749

Customer Service for Serta Perfect Sleeper Castara

The store itself is responsible for handling customer service.

Perhaps not the best customer service if mattresses are just one among thousands of available items.

Where to buy Serta Perfect Sleeper Castara

The Serta Perfect Sleeper Catara is available at physical stores only, including mattress warehouse.

From our unsatisfactory experience, we believe your money is better spent elsewhere with a mattress that is thoroughly tested, better quality, and comes with actual customer protection policies and 0-risk generous trials.

WIth something like our favorite hybrid mattress of 2023, the Layla Hybrid, you can just test it for 120 nights, and if you don't like it you can return it without any questions asked. Which is a much better experience than what physical mattress stores offer.

What Are Better Alternatives to the Serta Perfect Sleeper Castara Pillow Top (in 2023)?

These 5 mattresses (in 2023) are some of the best you can buy if you care about your health, your wallet, and your sleep:

  1. Layla Hybrid Mattress - Best Hybrid Mattress of 2023, hands down. All-around winner, fantastic for all sleep positions, top-notch quality, and the best looking mattress ever too. (Read our review of the Layla Hybrid here)
  2. Amerisleep AS2 Hybrid - Versatile, minimal, and great for responsive pressure relief. Balances between price & luxury.
  3. Nolah Evolution - High-tech features, aesthetically pleasing. Provides features exclusive to luxury mattresses for an unbeatable price.
  4. Zinus Green Tea - Even cheaper than the Serta Perfect Sleeper, and provides a night-and-day difference in quality & comfort.

Read our short, well-researched 10 Best Mattresses of 2023, here.

We did the homework so you can buy the perfect mattress without any hassle.

Serta Perfect Sleeper Castara Pillow Top Mattress Review Final Verdict

Overall Rating

3

out of 5

3 stars icon
firmness icon
Edge Support
4/5
pressure relief icon
Motion Isolation
2/5
price icon
Value
3.5/5
type icon
Materials
1.5/5
warranty icon
Company Policies
2/5
trial period icon
Pressure Relief
2/5
temperature icon
Temperature Regulation
3.5/5

Conclusion

Although the Serta Perfect Sleeper Castara Pillow Top Mattress has some advantages, especially the extremely low price point.

We recommend not cheaping out on your mattress and spine health; Thus, we think there are better alternatives that would be worth your money, especially in terms of construction quality, features, and customer protection 0-risk purchase policies.

This means you can get a proper luxury mattress and return it if after testing it for yourself and not being convinced that it's worth the price. However, we know that once you try a proper luxury mattress, you'll never go back to cheap mattresses.

In particular, from our experience we found that the Layla Hybrid Mattress is an excellent comparable direct alternative to the Serta Perfect Sleeper Castara Pillow Top.

The difference is that it is much more high-quality in nearly all aspects that you'd be looking for in Serta's offering, and will give you more than a decade (guaranteed under warranty) of healthy nights of sleep.

green verified icon
Verified Brand
Expert Pick

Layla Hybrid Mattress

Layla Hybrid Mattress

GET $200 OFF + 2 FREE Premium Pillows + Extra $50 Off at Checkout

clock icon
Expires Soon
people icon
Many People Bought Recently
coupons icon
Few Coupons Remaining
Exclusive Discount - Limited Time
Check Price
Jessica H.

Jessica H.

Jessica is a reviewer, writer, and sleep enthusiast at Sleepiverse. Jessica graduated with her master's degree in Nursing research and education. She is a registered nurse and currently works in the Intensive Care Unit. Since becoming a nurse, Jessica has worked the night shift, which means a disrupted sleep schedule. Knowing she needed to function at her best while caring for patients at night, she spent a lot of time researching how to sleep well with a difficult schedule.